Skip to content

Life Sciences

Recovery test or clean-up period in the URS

  • Life Sciences
  • 1 min read

A URS line that says "recovery within 15 minutes" can be read two ways, and the two readings lead to different tests.

The first is the recovery test in ISO 14644-3. You raise the particle concentration in the room, usually with an aerosol generator, then time how long it takes to fall by a factor of 100. It measures the air system: supply airflow, diffuser layout, how well the room mixes. It is done with the room as-built or at rest.

The second is the clean-up period in EU GMP Annex 1: the time for a room to return to its at-rest particle limits after operations finish. Annex 1 gives a guidance value of under 20 minutes and has the period set during qualification of the rooms. That one describes the room as it is used, with real people leaving and real equipment stopping.

They answer different questions. A room can recover 100:1 comfortably at OQ and then take longer than 20 minutes to settle after a shift, because a machine keeps shedding after it stops or a door was left propped open.

Our advice is to write the recovery test into the URS as the design acceptance criterion, with the method named, and to set the Annex 1 clean-up period during in-operation qualification, with real operations. Then nobody argues at OQ about which figure was meant.

Humiley writes the URS alongside the design, so the acceptance criterion and its test are chosen together.

Which one does your current URS actually specify?

Industries

Related

More on this subject

What ends the life of a HEPA filter

EU GMP Annex 1 (2022) asks for an integrity test of final filters at requalification and puts no age on the filter. A terminal HEPA is replaced when a leak cannot be repaired within site limits, when pressure drop reaches the manufacturer's final value, or after damage or wetting. On glass-fibre media, dust loading alone does not lower efficiency.

InsightRead

Zero growth and the HVAC record around a media fill

Annex 1 sets zero growth as the APS target, and any contaminated unit fails it. The environmental side of the investigation starts from viable monitoring, with HVAC and EMS trends as support, so review trends before the fill, confirm logging and clock sync, and agree which HVAC events count as interruptions.

InsightRead