Skip to content

Life Sciences

Blank fields in an executed protocol: close every one

  • Life Sciences
  • 1 min read

Page 14 of an executed OQ protocol has six result boxes. Four are filled in and two are empty.

An empty box can mean the test did not apply to this unit, or that the tester forgot it. It can also mean the space was left open for a value to be added after review, and a reviewer cannot rule that out.

EU GMP Chapter 4 says records should be made at the time each action is taken, and that any alteration should be signed and dated and leave the original entry readable. It has no sentence saying "no blank fields". The N/A convention comes from the site documentation procedure, and it is how the "complete" in ALCOA+ is met on paper: every field shows that someone decided about it.

In that procedure we would have the executor write N/A, initials and date in each unused field as they go. An unused table or page gets one diagonal line with the same three entries; forty separate N/As on a page invite a missed one. Where the reason is not obvious, one line gives it ("unit has no humidifier"). The reviewer returns the protocol for any blank and does not fill it in.

The better fix is upstream: generate the protocol for the unit as built, and most of the unused fields never appear.

Industries

Related

More on this subject

Calibration before OQ: installed transmitters count too

An OQ report can list certificates for every test instrument and none for the room pressure transmitters it reads. Before the first test, one sheet should cover both groups: certificate number, due date against the last test day and calibrated range against the test value, for the test kit and the installed sensors alike.

InsightRead

Batches of one product run back to back leave more baked-on product, packed fines and microbial growth for the final clean. The 2015 text of EU GMP Annex 15 (clause 10.9) says the maximum length of a campaign, in time and/or number of batches, should be the basis for cleaning validation. Set that maximum and validate after it.

InsightRead

CAPA: three terms that are usually mixed up

Replacing a failed part is a correction. Corrective action removes the cause so the failure does not recur, and preventive action removes the cause of a failure that has not happened yet. Each needs an owner, a date and a check that it worked; ICH Q10 and EU GMP Chapter 1 expect the effectiveness of the actions to be evaluated.

InsightRead