Skip to content

Life Sciences

Equipment equivalence starts with the operating principle

  • Life Sciences
  • 1 min read

Both sites have a 600 L mixer. One tumbles the powder in a bin and the other drives a ribbon through it.

On the gap analysis sheet the two rows match: mixer, 600 L, stainless steel. In the process they differ. A bin blender mixes by diffusion, particles rolling over each other as the container turns. A ribbon blender mixes by convection, the blade moving the bed. Blend time and fill level come out differently.

Equipment equivalence is what the sheet was supposed to test. The usual wording comes from the FDA's SUPAC guidance for immediate-release solid dosage forms. It treats a move to equipment of the same design and operating principles, of the same or of a different capacity, as its lowest level of equipment change, and a move to a different design and different operating principles as the next level. Its equipment addendum sorts machines into classes by operating principle, and tumble mixers and convection mixers are different classes.

That wording allows capacity to vary and holds the principle fixed, which is the reverse of a sheet that recorded only the 600 L.

In the WHO guidelines on technology transfer (Annex 4 of TRS 1044), the side-by-side comparison of equipment should be carried out in terms of working principle, capacity, make and model. On the gap analysis sheet, that is a column for operating principle beside the one for capacity, with blend time and fill level listed against it.

Industries

Related

More on this subject

Taking over a facility: start with a written gap assessment

Before changing an inherited facility or design, a written gap assessment against the URS and target regulations gives management and inspectors the same picture: evidence from documents and spot measurements, findings graded by risk, and the fix, cost range and schedule impact of each, plus what can stay.

InsightRead

EU GMP Annex 15 (2015) treats three consecutive PPQ batches as a common minimum, with the number justified from risk; the FDA's 2011 guidance names no count and works in three stages. A rationale that serves both draws on commercial-scale variability, parameters near their proven limits, prior knowledge and a statistical target on the CQAs.

InsightRead

10–15 Pa for FDA, 10 Pa for Annex 1: one cascade

FDA's 2004 aseptic guidance asks for at least 10–15 Pa between rooms of different classification; Annex 1 gives at least 10 Pa as guidance. Setting each cascade step at 15 Pa meets both. Holding it is harder: seals wear and filters load, so trend the differentials instead of waiting for alarms.

InsightRead