Skip to content

Life Sciences

What an audit trail must hold before anyone reviews it

  • Life Sciences
  • 1 min read

The first audit trail challenge at EMS OQ is a plain one: change a single setpoint and read back the entry it created.

21 CFR Part 11 section 11.10(e) asks for secure, computer-generated, time-stamped audit trails, and says a change must not obscure the value recorded before it. An entry reading only "setpoint changed" has lost the old value. EU GMP Annex 11 adds that the reason for a change or deletion of GMP-relevant data should be documented, so the entry needs old value, new value, user, time and reason.

Next, log in as an operator and then as a supervisor and look for any way to pause, edit or purge the trail. If either can, the people whose data it records control the record. Administrator rights belong to someone outside production and QC, and that account's own actions are audited too.

The time stamp is easy to miss. Move the workstation clock forward an hour, make a change, and see which time the entry carries. It should come from a clock users cannot set, usually a server synchronized to a network time source.

Archive readability cannot be shown on the day of OQ. Trails must stay readable for the retention period, including after a software upgrade, so the upgrade plan needs a step that opens an old trail.

We write the URS and validation strategy alongside the design, where these points are cheapest to settle.

Industries

Related

More on this subject

GMP on the electrical side

Where a SCADA, BMS or EMS records GMP-relevant data, access control, clock synchronization, alarm records and audit trails are decided by the electrical and automation engineers. Many sites keep those parameters on a separate validated EMS. Humiley's cross-functional training covers GMP, validation and project management.

InsightRead

Part 11 starts with the predicate rule

Part 11 applies to electronic records that a predicate rule such as 21 CFR 211 requires. For a BMS or EMS, name the rule behind each point: GMP-critical monitoring usually belongs in a validated EMS. For EU export, Annex 11 has no predicate-rule test, so the BMS still needs a risk assessment.

InsightRead

ALCOA+ on the EMS is a design requirement

Environmental monitoring and BMS data that support GMP decisions must meet ALCOA+. In practice that means individual logins, time-synchronized controllers, an audit trail users cannot disable, alarms acknowledged with name and comment, and tested backups, with GMP-critical parameters separated early onto a validated system.

Read