Skip to content

Manufacturing & Distribution

When supply and return are swapped at a cooling coil

  • Manufacturing & Distribution
  • 1 min read

Swap the two pipes on a cooling coil and it still cools, which is why the mistake survives commissioning.

A multi-row chilled water coil is selected for counterflow. Water enters at the row where the air leaves and exits at the row where the air enters, so the coldest water meets the coldest air and every row keeps a temperature difference to work with.

Piped the other way round, both streams run in the same direction. The first row does most of the work, and by the last row the water has warmed towards the air beside it. Take, say, a coil selected for water in at 7 °C and out at 13 °C, with air leaving at 12 °C. In parallel flow that duty cannot exist, because water at 13 °C cannot cool air that is already at 12 °C.

On the BMS it appears as a valve at 100%, return water colder than design and an off-coil temperature that misses setpoint on a wet afternoon. It reads like an undersized coil or a chiller fault, and people chase both before anyone looks at the headers.

The swap usually happens on site. The coil arrives with two plain stubs and the pipe route is easier one way than the other. Have the inlet and outlet marked at the factory, compare the marks with the manufacturer's connection drawing at FAT, and look at the pipework again before the insulation goes on. After that nobody will.

Related

More on this subject

Batch records and the room data behind them

Under EU GMP Chapter 4, paragraph 4.11, a product with a 5-year shelf life keeps its batch documentation for at least 6 years. Environmental and BMS data that supported release is safest kept for the same period, so historian retention and storage belong in the URS for the BMS and EMS.

InsightRead

Fixed-speed FFUs slow down as their HEPA loads

A fixed-speed fan filter unit loses airflow as its HEPA filter loads. Set at 0.45 m/s, it has 20% to lose before the 0.36 m/s bottom of the Annex 1 guidance range. Constant-airflow EC units hold velocity if they are selected at the final pressure drop, and their speed trend doubles as a filter-loading record.

InsightRead