Skip to content

Life Sciences

When test results are dated before the protocol approval

  • Life Sciences
  • 1 min read

Each OQ result, all of them within limits, carries a date four days earlier than the approval signature on the protocol.

That order means the acceptance criteria may have been written with the results already known. The tests may be sound, but the record can no longer show it.

EU GMP Annex 15 (2015) has no sentence that says "approve before you test". The text gets there in two steps: significant changes to the approved protocol during execution should be documented as a deviation, and results that fail the pre-defined acceptance criteria should be recorded as a deviation. "Approved" and "pre-defined" mean something only if the signature comes first. It also says the work should only be performed by suitably trained personnel, so the testers' training records need an earlier date too.

The usual cause is the calendar: the vendor's engineer leaves on Friday.

The annex leaves a route for earlier work: data obtained outside the manufacturer's own program may be used, provided the approach has been justified and there is adequate assurance that controls were in place while the data were acquired. Put that justification in the plan beforehand.

If the dates are already wrong, leave them as they are. Raise a deviation, assess what the early tests can still support, and repeat the rest under the approved protocol.

Industries

Related

More on this subject

Batch records and the room data behind them

Under EU GMP Chapter 4, paragraph 4.11, a product with a 5-year shelf life keeps its batch documentation for at least 6 years. Environmental and BMS data that supported release is safest kept for the same period, so historian retention and storage belong in the URS for the BMS and EMS.

InsightRead

Campaign length belongs in the cleaning validation

Batches of one product run back to back leave more baked-on product, packed fines and microbial growth for the final clean. The 2015 text of EU GMP Annex 15 (clause 10.9) says the maximum length of a campaign, in time and/or number of batches, should be the basis for cleaning validation. Set that maximum and validate after it.

InsightRead