Skip to content

Engineering Solution & Consultancy

A technology transfer package needs the reasons with the recipe

  • Engineering Solution & Consultancy
  • 1 min read

Following a batch record to the letter does not tell a receiving site why the drying stops where it does.

A transfer that ships only the recipe works until something differs: a granulator with another bowl geometry, an excipient from a new supplier. Then someone has to know which parameters can move, and the people who know are at the other site.

WHO TRS 1044, Annex 4, the technology transfer guideline, says the sending unit should make available all the necessary information and knowledge on the product, process or procedure. Its lists are long. Ask at kick-off for:

  1. The development report, with the history of the process and its changes.
  2. The master formula and executed batch records, with scale-up information.
  3. The control strategy with its justification: quality attributes, critical process parameters and the ranges that were qualified.
  4. Analytical procedures with their validation reports, and the stability data.
  5. Hold time studies, and cleaning information with solubility, cleanability and health-based exposure limits.

The batch records and methods nearly always arrive. The development history and the reasons behind the control strategy tend to arrive as a summary.

Our EU-GMP roadmap consulting covers QMS, CTD/eCTD dossier, technology transfer, MAH, QP and pharmacovigilance.

At your sending site, is the person who set the drying end-point still there to ask?

Industries

Related

More on this subject

The 2011 text of EU GMP Annex 11 (clause 6) says that where critical data are entered manually there should be an additional check on their accuracy, by a second operator or by validated electronic means. For a BMS or EMS alarm limit, a permitted range on the field and a confirmation step are the practical answer.

InsightRead

Annex 11 and the BMS-to-EMS link

The 2011 text of Annex 11 (clause 5) says systems that exchange data electronically should include built-in checks for correct and secure entry and processing. On a BMS-to-EMS link we read that as status flags, a communication watchdog, end-to-end checks of units and time stamps, and a loss-of-communication test in the qualification.

InsightRead

EU GMP Annex 11 clause 3.2 makes supplier competence and reliability part of computerized system validation, with the need for an audit set by risk. For SCADA, BMS and EMS, supplier records can reduce the testing the user repeats; the URS, risk assessment and configuration tests such as alarm limits and user roles stay with the user.

InsightRead