Skip to content

Engineering Solution & Consultancy

Commission first, qualify once

  • Engineering Solution & Consultancy
  • 1 min read

Two weeks ago an unsealed ceiling penetration was one line on a punch list. Found during an OQ pressure test, it is a deviation.

That means an investigation, a retest and a record an inspector will read, and it is the real price of starting qualification "in parallel" while the contractor closes punch items.

Commissioning and qualification can use the same instruments and even the same methods. What differs is what the result becomes. A commissioning run is engineering: find the problem, fix it, run again. A qualification test is GMP evidence, executed against an approved protocol, and a failure is documented as one.

So the order matters:

  1. Commission and balance the system until it performs, and keep those results.
  2. Close every punch item that could affect a qualification test, and name which ones they are.
  3. Then execute IQ and OQ, on a system you already expect to pass.

Qualification cannot start from an open punch list, but it can start early: turn over one AHU and its rooms at a time, so finished systems move on while construction carries on elsewhere.

In our EPCM work, construction to qualification is one of four handovers we manage explicitly, with FAT, SAT and commissioning records feeding into IQ.

Related

More on this subject

Two envelopes for a cleanroom HVAC tender

Score the technical envelope of a cleanroom HVAC tender and sign it off before any price is opened. Issue the scoring sheet with the tender: mandatory items pass or fail, the rest weighted, for example 40% technical depth and 20% each for documentation, delivery and service. Score every listed deviation.

InsightRead

A retention that pays for the turnover file

Most of a cleanroom HVAC contract is paid before the turnover documents exist. Split the retention into two parts, released on acceptance of the turnover package and of the documents, and size the documentation part on what it would cost the owner to finish as-builts, calibrations and retests without the contractor.

InsightRead