Skip to content

News

Deriving HVAC critical aspects from critical quality attributes

  • News
  • 1 min read

For a hygroscopic tablet, the quality attribute at risk is water content, and the HVAC critical aspect that follows from it is room RH.

ASTM E2500 asks verification to concentrate on critical aspects: the functions and features of a system that affect product quality and patient safety. On HVAC projects the list is often written from the equipment outward, and every fan, valve and sensor ends up called critical. Starting from the product gives a shorter list that holds up better.

The chain has four links.

  1. The product's critical quality attributes, from the development and process team: sterility, particulate, water content, degradation.
  2. The process steps where the room environment can move one of them.
  3. The HVAC critical aspects at those steps. Particle levels and airflow at an aseptic filling point, pressure differentials between grades, temperature and RH where the product is exposed.
  4. An acceptance criterion and a verification test for each one.

Everything outside the chain is still engineered and commissioned under good engineering practice. The chilled-water temperature, the fan speed and the coil valve matter because they deliver the room RH; the room RH is what gets qualified.

Humiley writes the URS and validation strategy in parallel with the design, so the chain exists before the first drawing is issued.

Related

More on this subject

Three APS runs across all shifts, and the HVAC has to hold still

Annex 1 initial validation of an aseptic process needs at least 3 consecutive successful simulations covering all working shifts, then periodic runs twice a year per process, line and shift. The cleanroom must hold its qualified state throughout. Agree an HVAC freeze date with QA, and list in advance which jobs are like-for-like and which need an impact assessment.

InsightRead

Value engineering after tender: savings that return at OQ

After an over-budget cleanroom HVAC tender, three savings recur: an EN 1886 L2 casing instead of L1, fewer room pressure transmitters, and deleted door drop-seals. Each can reappear as an OQ failure in airflow, alarm testing or pressure differentials, so check every line against its URS requirement and test before accepting it.

InsightRead

Annex 1 has applied since 25 August 2023

The revised EU GMP Annex 1 has applied since 25 August 2023, with point 8.123 following in 2024. A site still planning its gap assessment is years behind. Most findings land in the CCS, for example a pressure alarm delay set at commissioning that nobody can justify.

InsightRead