Skip to content

News

Nine determinations for accuracy, before and after ICH Q2(R2)

  • News
  • 1 min read

Nine determinations for accuracy is the figure everyone remembers from ICH Q2, and the 2023 revision reworded the sentence it came from.

Q2(R1) said accuracy should be assessed using a minimum of 9 determinations over a minimum of 3 concentration levels covering the specified range, for example 3 concentrations with 3 replicates each. Hence the 3 × 3 recovery table in almost every method validation report.

Q2(R2), adopted in November 2023, says accuracy should be assessed using an appropriate number of determinations and concentration levels covering the reportable range, and keeps the 3 × 3 design as its example in brackets. The words "a minimum of 9 determinations" remain under repeatability, as in Q2(R1), where the alternative is a minimum of 6 at 100% of the test concentration.

Accuracy should still be reported as mean percent recovery, or as the difference between the mean and the accepted true value, with a confidence interval. Q2(R2) adds that the interval should be compatible with the acceptance criterion unless otherwise justified.

For engineers this is awareness; the laboratory owns it. It reaches us when a cleaning validation or a water system qualification leans on a method.

Related

More on this subject

PIC/S GMP and EU GMP: who issues the certificate

The PIC/S GMP Guide and EU GMP are almost identical, revised Annex 1 included. In the EU the GMP principles are set in law and certificates sit in EudraGMDP; PIC/S authorities adopt the guide nationally and PIC/S certifies nothing. One design serves both; the EU inspection route is planned separately.

InsightRead