A HEPA leak scan by photometer needs an upstream aerosol load of roughly 10 to 100 mg/m³. That oil has to go somewhere.
ISO 14644-3 describes two ways to scan installed filters for leaks. The photometer measures aerosol mass downstream as a percentage of the upstream challenge, so it needs a heavy upstream load to see a small leak. The discrete particle counter counts individual particles, and works with an upstream concentration far lower than the photometer needs.
The photometer method is quick, familiar to most test contractors, and gives a direct percentage reading at the probe. The price is the challenge load. PAO or a similar oil aerosol loads the filter media, can leave residue downstream and, repeated at every requalification, adds up over the life of the filter.
The counter method is slower to set up and needs more care with sampling and statistics. It suits ULPA filters, where the leaks worth finding are too small for a photometer to resolve comfortably, and any filter bank you would rather not coat with oil every year, such as those over aseptic or semiconductor processes.
Our view: choose the method in the test protocol at design stage, together with the filter class and the housing's scan access, rather than leaving it to whichever contractor turns up.



