Skip to content

News

Tony Nguyen: ask what the room does when the door opens

  • News
  • 1 min read

The engineer presenting your cleanroom layout at a design review may be a recent graduate. That was my decision.

Qualified engineers in this field are scarce, so we built our engineering team from fresh graduates instead of waiting to hire experienced people. I have spent more than 20 years in automation, building systems and Life Sciences, and I knew training our own would be slower. It also means clients meet young engineers early in a project.

You are entitled to test them. Ask something the drawing does not answer. My choice would be what the room does when the door opens.

The drawing shows a Grade C room at 15 Pa above its Grade D corridor, every door shut. In use, people walk through that door all shift. While it is open the difference across it falls to almost nothing, and the Grade C side is protected by the air its supply keeps pushing out through the doorway. A trained engineer should say that, then explain how the pressure alarm delay is set so an ordinary passage does not trip it and a door propped open does. A complete answer ends with the test that shows the room is back in grade afterwards, which is recovery.

If the answer stops at "15 Pa", tell me directly, by email or at the review.

Which question do you put to a design team to find out whether they know how the room behaves in use?

Industries

Related

More on this subject

WFI belongs in the Contamination Control Strategy

EU GMP Annex 1 (2022) gives WFI circulation above 70 °C as an example of minimizing the risk of microbial growth. Keeping a loop hot drives the design: ASME BPE dead legs of L/D ≤ 2, turbulent flow to the last user point, planned sanitization and sensors on the return. The CCS should justify all of it.

InsightRead